News View Non-AMP

Ripple vs. SEC: The Agency’s Actions Could Backfire And Lead To Supreme Court Intervention

Published by
Nidhi Kolhapur

As Paul Atkins is set to replace Gary Gensler at the SEC, a new warning from JW Verret suggests that the agency risks severe consequences if it doesn’t drop the Ripple case. 

When the SEC launched its crusade against cryptocurrency, it didn’t expect to face resistance from the federal judiciary itself. The federal judges are challenging the SEC’s aggressive interpretation of old securities laws, which may eventually lead to the Supreme Court getting involved.

The dispute began with the SEC’s 2020 lawsuit against Ripple Labs, claiming the XRP token was an unregistered security. However, Judge Analisa Torres ruled that XRP sales on public exchanges were not securities transactions, a decision the SEC is appealing.

Judge Jed Rakoff’s Interpretation Could Have Serious Consequences

Judge Jed Rakoff took a broader view in the SEC’s case against Terraform Labs, suggesting that crypto tokens could be considered securities no matter how they are sold. This difference in judicial opinions has created legal uncertainty, which may lead to the Supreme Court stepping in.

Notably, Judge Rakoff’s interpretation could have serious consequences for the crypto industry. His view of the Howey test suggests that even trades of Luna tokens by people unrelated to Terraform could be considered securities. 

Lack Of Boundaries Raises Concerns

If this reasoning is followed further, even Bitcoin could be considered a security because its developers maintain the network. This could result in a broad expansion of SEC control, affecting everything from precious metals to airline rewards programs. This lack of clear boundaries raises concerns among legal experts and market participants.

The SEC’s appeal of the Ripple case could lead to problems, which could usher the Supreme Court to step in. The case could be used to limit the SEC’s power, stopping it from making decisions without clear approval from Congress.

Amid the Ripple vs SEC drama, find out what’s next for XRP read XRP price prediction for the latest insights on its market future!

SEC’s Approach Could Backfire

Coinbase is also battling the SEC, with the court questioning the SEC’s refusal to set clear rules for crypto trading, which could lead to Supreme Court involvement. By using the Howey test too broadly against legitimate crypto companies like Ripple, Coinbase, Kraken, and Uniswap without clear rules, the SEC risks limiting this important legal tool through Supreme Court intervention.

The SEC’s aggressive approach to cryptocurrency could backfire and harm its own authority. By continuing its appeal in the Ripple case and not providing clear rules, the SEC may prompt the Supreme Court to limit its powers. This could weaken the SEC’s ability to regulate crypto and impair its long-term goals, especially after the 2024 elections.

Nidhi Kolhapur

Nidhi is a Certified Digital Marketing Executive and Passionate crypto Journalist covering the world of alternative currencies. She shares the latest and trending news on Cryptocurrency and Blockchain.

Recent Posts

Choosing Between Ripple (XRP) and Cardano (ADA)? ChatGPT’s 2025 Prediction Could Change Everything

Investors often face a tough choice between Ripple's XRP and Cardano's ADA as potential winners…

April 25, 2025

Solana Price Analysis: Key Insights and Updates

Bullish momentum has been building up for Solana, amid a highly anticipated altseason before the…

April 25, 2025

Solana (SOL) Price Stuck at a Major Resistance—Can it Reach $180 in May 2025?

The crypto market, since the beginning of the second fortnight of the month, has been…

April 25, 2025

Here’s When Altcoins Like XRP, ADA and DOGE Will Rally

The crypto market is consolidating after a strong rally earlier this week, with Bitcoin holding…

April 25, 2025

Best Crypto to Buy Now as XRP Price Rallies

The XRP price rally has created fresh momentum in the crypto market, as Bitcoin moves…

April 25, 2025

2 Best Cryptos To Buy Under $0.50 That Analysts Say Could Skyrocket in 2025

In a market known for rapid moves and unpredictable trends, finding cryptocurrencies under $0.50 with…

April 25, 2025