News

Court Throws Out Crypto Developer’s Case and Hands Him a DOJ Memo Instead of Real Legal Protection

Published by
Debashree Patra and Anjali Belgaumkar

A U.S. court in Texas has dismissed a lawsuit filed by crypto developer Michael Lewellen, who was seeking legal clarity for his blockchain-based software. The case was thrown out by Reed O’Connor, who ruled that Lewellen failed to show a credible and imminent threat of prosecution.

Lewellen had asked the court to confirm that his Ethereum-based tool, Pharos, designed for charitable crowdfunding, would not violate money transmission laws. Reacting to the decision, he expressed disappointment, arguing that developers are still left without real legal certainty.

“A non-binding DoJ memo is no substitute for real legal certainty.”

In an X post, Lewellen maintained that his software does not control user funds and simply acts as a neutral tool, similar to an envelope used to send checks. Based on this, he argued it should not be regulated like services such as Western Union or Venmo.

His position was backed by major crypto advocacy groups, who warned that unclear legal definitions could stifle innovation across decentralized finance.

Court Relies on DOJ Memo, Critics Push Back

However, in its decision, the court leaned on a U.S. Department of Justice memo suggesting prosecutors would avoid targeting crypto platforms for users’ actions or unintended violations.

However, critics were quick to challenge this reasoning. Crypto analyst and critic, Peter Van Valkenburgh, argued that such memos are not legally binding and can be revised or revoked at any time. He stressed that they do not offer real protection to developers.

Lewellen shared a similar concern, stating that a non-binding memo cannot replace clear legal rules. Critics say the court effectively used a temporary policy as justification to avoid providing lasting judicial clarity.

Past Cases Raise Concerns

Skepticism also stems from recent enforcement actions. Developers linked to Tornado Cash and Samourai Wallet faced prosecution and prison sentences for operating unlicensed money transmitting businesses.

Although Judge O’Connor distinguished those cases, highlighting their alleged links to money laundering, critics argue the outcomes show that developers still face real risks despite policy signals from regulators.

Industry Reaction: “Missed Opportunity”

The ruling has drawn strong reactions from across the crypto space. Policy voices like Jonathan Schmalfeld called the decision a “hugely disappointing result,” arguing that if current guidance were truly protective, ongoing cases like that of Roman Storm would not exist.

“Whether through market structure or elsewhere, developer protections MUST be codified into law.”

Many believe the court missed a key opportunity to define the legal boundaries for developers, leaving them in uncertainty.

FAQs

What legal risks do crypto developers face after this ruling?

Developers may still face investigations or charges if authorities interpret their software as enabling financial activity, even without direct control of funds.

Who is most affected by the lack of legal clarity in crypto laws?

Independent developers, startups, and open-source contributors are most exposed, as they lack resources to handle legal uncertainty or enforcement risks.

What could happen next after this court decision?

Future cases may revisit similar issues, or lawmakers could introduce clearer legislation to define when crypto software qualifies as money transmission.

Debashree Patra and Anjali Belgaumkar

Fun-loving and cheerful, a passionate blockchain and crypto writer who knows no boundary…connect if you share the same passion. With 10+ years of writing experience, I am a Crypto Journalist by chance, exploring, and learning all the dynamics of the sci-fi action-filled crypto world. Currently, focusing on cryptocurrency news and price data. With a passion for research and challenging my capabilities, I am slowly getting into the crypto arena to bring new insights every day.

Recent Posts

Google Stock Price Today and News

Alphabet shares rose 1.24% in premarket trading on Wednesday to $281.04, up $3.44 from Tuesday’s…

November 18, 2026

XRP Price Struggles Near $1, But Network Growth Signals a Reversal – What’s Next?

The broader crypto market is still struggling to find its footing after the recent sell-off,…

November 18, 2026

When Is the Anthropic IPO?

Anthropic is scheduled to finalise its IPO pricing on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, with shares…

November 18, 2026

Iran Kuwait Latest US Strike Triggers Retaliatory Attack on Kuwait Base

Iran has launched attacks targeting US military installations in Kuwait following American air strikes on…

November 18, 2026

XRP Rich List Shows Smaller Holders Added 504 Million XRP in a Year

The XRP rich list shows that smaller holders continued accumulating XRP even as the price…

November 18, 2026

Ethereum MEV Exploit Case Collapses as Judge Acquits Brothers

The Ethereum MEV exploit case has ended in acquittal after a US federal judge cleared…

November 18, 2026